Disclaimer: The Attribution Nuance
Actor clustering and naming are interpretations by specific researchers or vendors. For most organizations, prioritizing generic detection of TTPs (Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures) offers higher defensive value than definitive attribution. Formal attribution is primarily the domain of Law Enforcement and Government entities with the authority to pursue legal or physical recourse.
TL;DR: Attribution is subjective. Focus on detecting TTPs to protect your network; leave identifying the โwhoโ to Law Enforcement.
flowchart LR M["๐ฒ๐พ Malaysia"] --o C["๐จ๐ณ China"] M --o I["๐ฎ๐ฑ Israel"] M --o U["๐บ๐ธ USA"] M --o N["๐ฐ๐ต North Korea"] M --o R["๐ท๐บ Russia"] M --o I1["๐ฎ๐ฉ Indonesia"] M --o I2["๐ฎ๐ณ India"] M --o I3["๐ฎ๐ท Iran"] M --o K["๐ฐ๐ท South Korea"] M --o U1["Uncategorized"] R --> A1[APT28] R --> A2[APT29] I2 --> A3[RAZOR-TIGER] I2 --> A4[QUILTED-TIGER] I2 --> A5[HAZY-TIGER] I3 --> A6[Fox-Kitten] C --> A7[UNC3886] C --> A8[APT15] C --> A9[APT23] C --> A10[APT30] C --> A11[APT40] C --> A12[APT41] C --> A13[Earth-Estries] C --> A14[Earth-Lusca] C --> A15[RedJuliett] C --> A16[RedDelta] C --> A17[HAFNIUM] C --> A18[GALLIUM] C --> A19[Platinum] C --> A20[Hellsing] C --> A21[Naikon] C --> A22[LOTUS-PANDA] C --> A23[GOBLIN-PANDA] C --> A24[Evasive-Panda] C --> A25[Aoqin-Dragon] C --> A26[TA428] C --> A27[Worok] C --> A28[Earth-Longzhi] U1 --> A29[SOLAR-SPIDER] U1 --> A30[ToddyCat] U1 --> A31[LabHost] U1 --> A32[ScamClub] U1 --> A33[El-Machete] U1 --> A34[Orangeworm] U1 --> A35[Cobalt] U1 --> A36[Thrip] U1 --> A37[Roaming-Mantis] N --> A38[Lazarus-Group] K --> A39[DarkHotel] U --> A40[Equation-Group] I1 --> A41[INDOHAXSEC-TEAM] click A1 "/tags/APT28" _blank click A2 "/tags/APT29" _blank click A3 "/tags/RAZOR-TIGER" _blank click A4 "/tags/QUILTED-TIGER" _blank click A5 "/tags/HAZY-TIGER" _blank click A6 "/tags/Fox-Kitten" _blank click A7 "/tags/UNC3886" _blank click A8 "/tags/APT15" _blank click A9 "/tags/APT23" _blank click A10 "/tags/APT30" _blank click A11 "/tags/APT40" _blank click A12 "/tags/APT41" _blank click A13 "/tags/Earth-Estries" _blank click A14 "/tags/Earth-Lusca" _blank click A15 "/tags/RedJuliett" _blank click A16 "/tags/RedDelta" _blank click A17 "/tags/HAFNIUM" _blank click A18 "/tags/GALLIUM" _blank click A19 "/tags/Platinum" _blank click A20 "/tags/Hellsing" _blank click A21 "/tags/Naikon" _blank click A22 "/tags/LOTUS-PANDA" _blank click A23 "/tags/GOBLIN-PANDA" _blank click A24 "/tags/Evasive-Panda" _blank click A25 "/tags/Aoqin-Dragon" _blank click A26 "/tags/TA428" _blank click A27 "/tags/Worok" _blank click A28 "/tags/Earth-Longzhi" _blank click A29 "/tags/SOLAR-SPIDER" _blank click A30 "/tags/ToddyCat" _blank click A31 "/tags/LabHost" _blank click A32 "/tags/ScamClub" _blank click A33 "/tags/El-Machete" _blank click A34 "/tags/Orangeworm" _blank click A35 "/tags/Cobalt" _blank click A36 "/tags/Thrip" _blank click A37 "/tags/Roaming-Mantis" _blank click A38 "/tags/Lazarus-Group" _blank click A39 "/tags/DarkHotel" _blank click A40 "/tags/Equation-Group" _blank click A41 "/tags/INDOHAXSEC-TEAM" _blank
List of Related Threat Actors
- APT15
- APT23
- APT28
- APT29
- APT30
- APT37
- APT40
- Aoqin-Dragon
- Cobalt
- DarkHotel
- Earth-Estries
- Earth-Longzhi
- Earth-Lusca
- El-Machete
- Equation-Group
- Evasive-Panda
- Evil-Corp
- Fox-Kitten
- GALLIUM
- GOBLIN-PANDA
- HAFNIUM
- HAZY-TIGER
- Hellsing
- INDOHAXSEC-TEAM
- Kimsuky
- LOTUS-PANDA
- LabHost
- Lazarus-Group
- Naikon
- Operation-C-Major
- Orangeworm
- PLATINUM
- QUILTED-TIGER
- RAZOR-TIGER
- RedDelta
- RedJuliett
- Roaming-Mantis
- Rupert-Group
- R00TK1T
- SOLAR-SPIDER
- ScamClub
- Sowbug
- TA428
- Thrip
- Thrip
- ToddyCat
- UNC3886
- Worok